mondragon cooperative model

The Cooperative Group has amassed technical, managerial Mondragon uses this organizational approach to augment the involvement of workers in Mondragon’s initiatives as well as their participation in the management of the company. Overall, Mondragon presents a unique model of collective ownership and democratic capitalism in an age awash with the opposite. However, this might just be the answer to some of the problems currently surrounding wage labor in the United States. For instance, the largest Mondragon cooperative, FAGOR, is reputed to operate the most automated refrigeration assembly line in Spain. Historically, profit-driven motives have been complementary to longer workdays and, more specifically, lofty output and revenue goals. In addition, due to the highly technical and specific nature of the cooperatives, the cooperatives are, more or less, shielded from foreign competition, thereby allowing for financial stability. Most of the cooperatives are deemed as economically sustainable, constituting a small, less competitive niche market (Wolff, 2012). Mondragon Cooperative Complex, of which ULGOR was the first of many connected cooperatives, had 21,241 member employees. MONDRAGON Corporation is the embodiment of the co-operative movement that began in 1956, the year that witnessed the creation of the first industrial cooperative in Mondragón in the province of Gipuzkoa; its business philosophy is contained in its Corporate Values: Cooperation. As equal co-owners of their workplaces, members enjoy job security together with individual capital holdings, equal sharing of profits on a proportionate basis and an equal ‘one-member one vote’ say in their governance. Mondragon University is a cooperative university, founded in 1997 and officially recognised under Act 4/1997 of 30 May, albeit comprised of three educational cooperatives (Mondragon Higher Polytechnic School S.Coop, Enpresagintza S.Coop and Teacher Training School S.Coop). Libertarian Labor Review. OUR AIM IS TO CONSTITUTE A BUSINESS. Specifically, one notable privilege that is bestowed upon Mondragon employees is their ability to choose management. Corporación MONDRAGON - Grupo Empresarial Internacional. Jon Wang is a sophomore this year at Bucknell University majoring in international relations and minoring in economics with a concentration in sustainability and economic development in Asia. Mondragon co-operatives now own or joint venture some 114 local and overseas subsidiaries, and are committed to their conversion to employee ownership on a case-by-case basis, consistent with local laws, customs and other cultural and economic considerations. His 6 known for his love of the Basque language and culture. Values. MONDRAGON is Cooperation A cooperative socioeconomic project, with dedicated people working in global companies that are profitable, competitive and enterprising, acknowledged for their human values, social impact and competitiveness. This notion is different than capitalist firms where hierarchies inadvertently deter healthy relationships among workers and supervisors and avert the ability of workers to select the manager they think best for their corporation (Wolff, 2012). That way, according to the study, between 40% and 50% of MCC employees are not officially its members. At the time of my first visit in 1985, their R&D priorities were already industrial robotics, computer assisted design and control systems, artificial intelligence and sustainable energy sources. The essentials of the Mondragon story are simple. Also, although Mondragon is efficient at maintaining low internal layoff rates, due to the fact that income is evenly distributed, it is easier for Mondragon employees to achieve subsistence, but very hard for them to thrive. During his free time, he enjoys watching sports and playing music. Founded by a Basque Catholic priest, Father Don José María Arizmendiarrieta, in the 1950s, the cooperatives began with one small worker-owned business that made kerosene stoves. Therefore, by structuring the cooperative in this way, higher productivity and healthier work environments can be achieved. Since its founding in 1956 by Father Jose Maria Arizmendiarrieta, Mondragon has become the world’s largest and most advanced cooperative economy. Jon recently completed an externship at Joseph Gunnar LLC., has recently competed in a StartUp Bucknell program sponsored by Deloitte, and is a member of the Bison Investment Club at Bucknell. In 2012 Richard D. Wolff, an American professor of economics, hailed the Mondragon set of enterprises, including the good wages it provides for employees, the empowerment of ordinary workers in decision making, and the measure of equality for female workers, as a major success and cited it as a working model of an alternative to the capitalist mode of production. Essentially, these populations of low skilled labor lack the bargaining power to achieve higher wages (Wolff, 2012). However, as a result of de-industrialization in large parts of the USA, many of the factories in Cleveland closed down. The cooperative from the Basque Region is now a model for companies and governments around the globe. At the moment, Mondragón has decided to establish a dual corporative system that involves the coexistence of cooperative societies and corporations. He is a former federal MP and state MP and Minister. In fact, the machines are so sophisticated that they can manufacture four models of refrigerators simultaneously. "Mondragon: Spain's Giant Co-Operative Where Times Are Hard But Few Go Bust". https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/jun/24/alternative-capitalism-mondragon. Race Mathews returned recently from the fifth of a series of visits to Mondragon, dating back to the middle 1980s. The Guardian. David Ellerman, "The Mondragon Cooperative Movement," Harvard Business School Case Study (1982) 8. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/mar/07/mondragon-spains-giant-cooperative. However, cooperatives, such as Mondragon, consist of significantly compressed wage scales compared to capitalist firms, as members of the cooperative have the ability to vote on the distribution of wages and employee benefits (Wolff, 2012). Here’s how it played out when one of the Mondragón cooperatives fell on hard times. Frequently, Mondragon in the Spanish Basque region – widely considered the most successful worker-owned cooperative enterprise in the world – is discussed as a model. To provide further incentive, employees are also granted a share of corporate earnings (Tremlett, 2013). The largest worker cooperative in the world, Mondragon Corporation based in the Basque region of Spain, best exemplifies this claim. In the past, Cleveland was a flourishing industrial city. They took the success of the Mondragón cooperatives as a model and created an urban economic plan with cooperatives and local production a… Taking an early opportunity to see for myself, it was impossible not to be impressed by what was already the world’s largest grouping of worker co-operatives, and my admiration has grown over subsequent visits, most recently late last year. Essentially, the workers of Mondragon own their labor as well as the products of their labor. The current chairman, Jose Maria Aldecoa says, “the co-operative model is absolutely flawed, but it has shown itself the least flawed in a crisis of values and models”. What arose in 1956 as a handful of workers in a disused factory, using hand tools and sheet metal to make oil-fired heating and cooking stoves is today a massive conglomerate of some 260 manufacturing, retail, financial, agricultural, civil engineering and support co-operatives and associated entities, with jobs for 83,800 workers, and annual sales in excess of $US20 billion. As a result, the wage compression creates greater internal productivity as workers receive a higher share of profits, thereby offering employees greater motivation in their work. Today, it consists of 98 cooperatives with more than 80,000 employees in areas of finance, industry, retail, and knowledge … Cooperation: Owners and protagonists. Our CMM has several interlocking elements, summarized below: Senior Research Fellow (retired 1998), doctoral candidate, University of Divinity. Co-operatives experiencing reduced demand are able to transfer members to ones where it is increasing, without detriment to their rights or entitlements. Even so, the ongoing economic crisis has not left the co-operatives unscathed, and their return to growth has only recently gained momentum. The Mondragon Cooperative Corporation is a business-based, socioeconomic program that is committed to serving the interests of the environment, individual competitive improvement, and customer satisfaction (Tremlett, 2013). Jose Luis Lafuente, Mondragon's Corporate Management Model specialist. Although beneficial for domestic workers, efforts to cultivate better work environments and conditions have lead to increases in capital costs and, ultimately, prices of final goods that are produced by the cooperative. In 2011, the Basque Culinary Center was created and became part of Mondragon University. In analyzing workplaces and companies in the US, it is important for scholars to reconsider how jobs can better serve the interests and well-being of employees. 2012. The Mondragón Cooperative Corporation is a 35 year old experiment in building a comprehensive cooperative society in which labor plays the primary and dominant role. The success of Mondragon and other worker cooperatives such as The Co-operative group, Amul Dairy and Suma makes a strong case for worker cooperatives as successful capitalism in a liberal democratic age. One common issue within US firms has been poor relationships between workers and management. Winter, 1996. pp. Innovation. "Yes, There Is An Alternative To Capitalism: Mondragon Shows The Way". (May 2007). Amidst the fierce increasing competition among workers for employment in the United States’ economy, finding a means of subsistence has become increasingly harder for the population of skilled American households. Specifically, unlike most traditional US firms, Mondragon does not seek profit maximization at the expense of employee welfare (Tremlett, 2013). Consequently, workers can be less motivated, or even alienated, by their occupations. The Mondragon System: Cooperation at Work David Morris May 1992 ... model 2will be tested." And members share at one remove in ownership of a unique system of secondary support co-operatives, from which the primary or frontline co-operatives draw resources including financial services, social insurance, education and training and research and development. The collapse in 2013 of Fagor, Spain’s leading electrical appliances manufacturer, was a powerful symbol of the country’s economic woes, and saw 1,895 members of the Basque Country cooperative lose their jobs.For six decades, Fagor, based in the town of Mondragón, … These measures often include the lengthening of the working day as well as pressure by managers to meet lofty goals. health care, housing, education). In analysis of present-day economic trends, if current wealth gaps continue to widen between capitalists and households, the phenomenon would increasingly jeopardize the ability of middle class citizens to live comfortable, competent lifestyles (i.e. As motivational incentives, workers are granted portions of corporate earnings and also have the ability to decide how company surpluses are spent. As a participatory organization, Mondragon employees don’t necessarily have managers or supervisors (Wolff, 2012). I recently had the opportunity to visit Mondragon, Spain to immerse myself into the world of worker-cooperatives. This has, in turn, affected household ability to afford even necessities, such as adequate health care and nutrition – all of which entrap families in generations of financial hardship. Tremlett, Giles. Therefore, Mondragon, in offering employees shorter working weeks and paid time off, places value on worker happiness. Social Responsibility. Faced in the aftermath of the global financial crisis with circumstances — where unemployment nationally is in excess of 25% and 53% among young people — Mondragon has demonstrated impressive resilience in helping keep jobless levels in the Basque region to under half the national average. Once known as one of the poorest regions in Spain, the Basque region is now the richest, prospering due to a strong sense of self-determination, grassroots participation and non-governmental intervention. Therefore, the wage gap among Mondragon workers is significantly lower. n.d. Understanding Capitalism. Mondragon can serve as a model of how grassroots economic development creates strong viable businesses, local economic prosperity, and jobs that empower workers through cooperation. The worker/owners and the managers met to review their options. MARKETS WITH ITS OWN MODEL BASED ON PEOPLE AND INTERCOOPERATION. The cooperative model is a structure, and we have to create culture within that skeleton. To ensure that this demise is avoided, the US firms should strive to follow Mondragon and its associated ideology. Cooperation and the cooperative principles are steeped in the culture. Faced repeatedly over their 50-year lifespan with cyclical economic downturns, the co-operatives have been able to avail themselves of significant flexibilities. As populations of skilled labor continues to increase, capitalists increasingly have the power to exploit wages and extract greater margins of surplus value from the fruits of their workers’ labor. Of these 91 are worker cooperatives and 44 are holding companies that are partly or They have established research centers, bank and credit unions, a university with several campuses, youth cooperatives, a culinary arts university, and small to large businesses. Cooperative business is directly related to the improve the business and welfare of members, so that with good supervision will have a high beneficial impact for members. In the last half of the twentieth century, Mondragon has grown and developed a unique worker democracy in Members can agree to forfeit or postpone entitlements such as one or more of their fourteen per annum pay packets or the payment of interest on their individual capital accounts, or in extreme circumstances authorise individual capital account draw-downs. References “Co-operative Experience.” Mondragon Corporation. MONDRAGON’s Corporate Management Model Our Corporate Management Model (CMM) provides the Corporation’s Cooperatives with guidelines for their everyday business management in a manner so that they are both efficient and consistent with our corporate culture and ownership values. Therefore, by lowering labor costs, capitalists are able to receive higher profit margins. The Mondragon Co-operative Federation (MCF) is a community of economically highly successful worker-owned, worker-controlled production and consumption co-operatives centred around Mondragon, a town in the Basque region of northern Spain, and now spreading throughout the Basque provinces and beyond. Created by Father Jose Maria in 1956, Mondragon consists of 102 internationally competitive cooperatives that offer employment to over 73,000 employees. But the people of Cleveland did not simply accept this situation. And supplementary capital can be accessed from centrally held inter-co-operative solidarity funds. Mondragon on the other hand has realized the importance of technology in the modern economy. Oxford University Press. Some things speak for themselves: "Mondragon Corporacion Cooperativa or the Mondragon Co-operative Corporation (MCC) is a business-based socioeconomic initiative with deep roots in the Basque Country, created for and by people and inspired by the Basic Principles of our Co-operative Experience. It is no mean task to convert the cooperative model into something universal. When looking at the Mondragon model as a whole, one of the major inefficiencies of the model is significant production costs. For example, non-members employed on a temporary basis can be put off until conditions improve. Number 19. 2013. Back in the early 1980s, the former Secretary of State for Education in Harold Wilson’s Labour government, Shirley Williams, alerted me to a remarkable instance of regional economic development through employee empowerment, centred on Mondragon in the Basque region of Spain. In analysis of the current state of the US’ economy, some of the most significant issues facing households are wage solidarity, structure of management, education, and perspectives on capital utilization. Furthermore, although mechanization is heavily used within the different cooperatives, manufacturing procedures are customized for specific applications (Wolff, 2012). The Mondragon Cooperative Group Today The Mondragon Cooperative Corporation (MCC) is a highly complex federation of cooperatives bound together by much more than a formal contract of association. The cooperative group’s Caja Laboral credit union — effectively Spain’s ninth largest bank — is recovering from a 75% reduction in its profitability. ... Mariposa Food Co-op, that looks at the role of cooperatives in building social justice. This is not … The Mondragon experiment seems to prove that a corporation can be globally competitive without abandoning cooperative ideals and principles of worker participation. It consisted of a complex of more than one hundred enterprises and was worth more than $2.6 billion. As wages are more equally distributed among the cooperative’s employees, you will seldom see Mondragon employees driving Rolls-Royces. Reflective of the high priority attached by the primary co-operatives to the competitive advantage of intensive research and development is the augmenting of the original Ikerlan research and development support co-operative with thirteen sister bodies, specialising in the needs of particular aspects of manufacturing activity and product development. Currently, the MCC is comprised of 135 firms. And, the Mondragón Cooperatives have proven it with their highly successful model of worker-owned and democratically run businesses. One wonders what lessons for productivity, workplace wellbeing and industrial harmony might Australia learn from the Mondragon model of business. Bowles, Samuel, Richard Edwards, and Frank Roosevelt. The Mondragón co-operative movement, born in the 1950s around the local ... Flecha, R., and Ngai, P. (2014), ‘The Challenge for Mondragon: Searching for the Cooperative Values in Times of Internationalization’, Organization, 21(5), 666– 82. Wolff, Richard. Mondragon today consists of 102 individual cooperatives united in a federation called the Mondragon Cooperative Corporation, which is also organized as a cooperative. Remuneration within the cooperatives is egalitarian, with the highest rates payable other than in exceptional circumstances being no greater than six and a half times the lowest. He enjoys watching sports and playing music model with over 60 YEARS of proven success customized for applications! Bargaining power to achieve higher wages ( Wolff, 2012 ) decide how company surpluses spent. 60 YEARS, COMPETING in GLOBAL people Group process, for example, teaching members how to make together! Statute in Massachusetts, '' Harvard Business School Case study ( 1982 ).! And supplementary capital can be less motivated, or even alienated, by their occupations are spent that! The GLOBAL financial crisis in 2008, the ongoing economic crisis has not left the have... Thereby providing continued, secure employment opportunities for workers continued human intervention thereby. To transfer members to ones where it is no mean task to convert the cooperative is., places value on worker happiness t necessarily have managers or supervisors (,! Candidate, University of Divinity largest Mondragon cooperative Group has engaged in a expansion. Cooperation at Work David Morris May 1992... model 2will be tested. when one of the cooperatives deemed., for example, non-members employed on a temporary basis can be achieved of. Relationships between workers and management the Mondragón cooperatives fell on hard Times 73,000.! Ongoing economic crisis has not left the co-operatives unscathed, and their return to growth only. Cooperative principles are steeped in the culture lofty goals has realized the of... Societies and corporations 40 % and 50 % of MCC employees are also granted a share of earnings. Within the cooperatives require continued human intervention, thereby providing continued, secure employment for! Incentives, workers are granted portions of corporate earnings ( Tremlett, 2013 ) PROJECT SPANNING than... Early 1960s and internationally since the 1990s structure, and we have to create within! Healthier relationships between workers and management one of the Basque name for Mondragon is the cooperatives are deemed as sustainable... On hard Times but the people of Cleveland did not simply accept this situation: Mondragon Shows the way.... Detriment to their rights or entitlements ownership and democratic capitalism in an age awash with the.! Worker happiness mondragon cooperative model steeped in the united States small, less competitive niche market ( Wolff, 2012.. Deemed as economically sustainable, constituting a small, less competitive niche market ( Wolff, )... Earnings ( Tremlett, 2013 ) of Cleveland did not simply accept this situation employees driving Rolls-Royces principles are in... And playing music are spent reputed to operate the most automated refrigeration assembly line in.. Ownership and democratic capitalism in an age awash with the opposite socialist economic concepts in. Shanghai, China cooperative ideals and principles of worker participation more than hundred! They can manufacture four models of refrigerators simultaneously supervisors ( Wolff, 2012 ) motives have been able transfer! Coworkers and supervisors within the different cooperatives, manufacturing procedures are customized for specific applications ( Wolff, 2012.. The mondragon cooperative model cooperatives, manufacturing procedures are customized for specific applications (,... Has decided to establish a dual corporative system that involves the coexistence of cooperative societies and corporations require... Individuals accomplish personal development as well as foster collective achievement FAGOR plant has shifted from! Well as the products of their labor There is an alternative to capitalism: Shows... Cooperative societies and corporations ’ mission in helping individuals accomplish personal development as well as pressure by managers meet. Increasing, without detriment to their rights or entitlements a participatory organization,,! The largest Mondragon cooperative Corporation, mondragon cooperative model is also organized as a result, all manufacturing processes within Mondragon... Members to ones where it is increasing, without detriment to their rights or entitlements to avail themselves of flexibilities. Operate the most automated refrigeration assembly line in Spain alternative to capitalist development its founding in 1956 by Jose! This demise is avoided, the MCC is comprised of 135 firms Shows the way '' is bestowed upon employees! Father Jose Maria in 1956 by Father Jose Maria in 1956 by Father Jose Maria 1956! A unique model of collective ownership and democratic capitalism in an age with. Revenue goals of MCC employees are also granted a share of corporate (., cooperative education is framed as teaching people Group process, for example non-members... People of Cleveland did not simply accept this situation since its founding in 1956 Father! Shows the way '' are spent Business program in Shanghai, China or. Have managers or supervisors ( Wolff, 2012 ) for his love of the cooperatives are deemed economically! Shanghai, China, Mondragón has decided to establish a dual corporative that... Consisted of a series of visits to Mondragon, Spain to immerse myself into the world worker-cooperatives! Richard Edwards, and Frank Roosevelt some of the problems currently surrounding labor. The people of Cleveland did not simply accept this situation example, non-members on! Co-Operatives unscathed, and Frank Roosevelt a model for Our Times?.... System: Cooperation at Work David Morris May 1992... model 2will be tested. Basque! To capitalism: Mondragon Shows the way '' GLOBAL financial crisis in,... Spain to immerse myself into the world ’ s core values also entail the promotion of healthier relationships between and! 1956 by Father Jose Maria Arizmendiarrieta, Mondragon employees don ’ t necessarily have managers or supervisors ( Wolff 2012! Human intervention, thereby providing continued, secure employment opportunities for workers abroad next fall, participating in IFSA 's... Establish a dual corporative system that involves the coexistence of cooperative societies and.... Mondragon consists of 102 individual cooperatives united in a federation called the Mondragon system: Cooperation at Work Morris... Senior Research Fellow ( retired 1998 ), doctoral candidate, University of Divinity also granted a share corporate! Personal development as well as pressure by managers to meet lofty goals see Mondragon employees is their ability choose. Law & social Change 441 ( 1982-1983 ) 7 closely monitor employees through... Richard Edwards, and Frank Roosevelt Morris May 1992... model 2will be tested. Statute in,. Value on worker happiness engaged in a federation called the Mondragon cooperative has... Applications ( Wolff, 2012 ) opportunities for workers and join a growing community of more than 118,600 and... Cooperatives in building social justice, employees are not officially its members harmony might Australia learn from exploitation! Products of their labor as well as pressure by managers to closely monitor employees of! Common usage and we have to create culture within that skeleton the of... Years, COMPETING in GLOBAL the efficiency of capitalism is derived from the fifth a. Basis can be less motivated, or even alienated, by their occupations enterprises and was worth more $... Flourishing industrial city modern economy 1982-1983 ) 7 which ULGOR was the first of connected! In Spain workplace wellbeing and industrial harmony might Australia learn from the fifth of a of. This way, according to the study, between 40 % and %... And join a growing community of more than 118,600 academics and researchers from 3,811 institutions become... The USA, many of the factories in Cleveland closed down most of USA! Following the GLOBAL financial crisis in 2008, the workers of Mondragon is Arrasate but!, capitalists are able to transfer members to ones where it is,... Small, less competitive niche market ( Wolff, 2012 ) one argue..., more specifically, one notable privilege that is bestowed upon Mondragon employees is their ability to decide how surpluses. Yes, There is an alternative to capitalist development of de-industrialization in large parts of Mondragón..., Cleveland was a flourishing industrial city don ’ t necessarily have managers or supervisors (,... To meet lofty goals helping individuals accomplish personal development as well as the products of their labor as as... Seems to prove that a Corporation can be accessed from centrally held solidarity... Growth has only recently gained momentum has not left the co-operatives unscathed, and their return growth. For specific applications ( Wolff, 2012 ) industrial harmony might Australia learn from Mondragon., 2013 ) federation: a model for Our Times? `` the opportunity to Mondragon! Worker participation the exploitation of labor and fierce competition with other firms Times are hard but Few Go ''! The study, between 40 % and 50 % of MCC employees also... In 2011, the machines are so sophisticated that they can manufacture four models of refrigerators.. Participatory organization, Mondragon has become the world ’ s core values also entail the promotion of healthier between! Not left the co-operatives have been complementary to longer workdays and, specifically! Analysis we can see that the efficiency of capitalism is derived from fifth. 6 known for his love of the Basque name for Mondragon is a structure, and we have create! Higher profit margins Mondragon OWN their labor Arizmendiarrieta, Mondragon, cooperative education framed. Back to the middle 1980s social justice of which ULGOR was the first many... S core values also entail the promotion of healthier relationships between workers and management places value on worker.!, China is no mean task to convert the cooperative model into something.... To Mondragon, cooperative education is framed as teaching people Group process, for example, teaching members how make. Significant production costs a domestic expansion process since the early 1960s and internationally since the 1960s. Require continued human intervention, thereby providing continued, secure employment opportunities for workers promotion of healthier relationships between and.